A local newspaper company that has newspapers in Fayette, Highland, and Madison Counties, to name a few, said in an email they were planning to launch an online database compiled of those who have a concealed carry weapon permit.
According to an internal email provided by a confidential source, Civitas Media, which owns 88 newspapers across the country, including the Fayette County Record Herald, Madison County’s Madison Press, and Highland County’s Times Gazette, has discussed the use of “public records act requests” to “build state-by-state databases that list those who have the right to carry” firearm licenses.
The email, dated January 19, 2014, was written by Civitas Media’s director of content, Jim Lawitz, and distributed to content directors, managers, and producers at company-owned newspapers in 12 states, including 38 newspapers here in Ohio.
The email read in part, “The second project examines the explosion of ‘conceal and carry’ gun permits across the U.S. Through public records act requests, we will attempt to build state-by-state databases that list those who have the right to carry a concealed weapon.”
When asked to discuss the email further, Lawitz said in a statement to the Buckeye Firearms Association, “We do not typically publicly comment on internal proprietary communication. However, we have no plans to publish any names on any lists. Further, we are open to discuss any published reports.”
Fayette Advocate reached out to locally-owned Civitas newspaper Record Herald, based in Washington Court House, for comment. Content Manager Ryan Carter responded with a statement from Civitas’ C.E.O. Michael Bush.
Bush said in his statement that the company doesn’t have plans to move forward with the database and blamed the uproar on “a poorly crafted” memo.
“Civitas Media never had any plans or intentions of publishing in print or online lists of holders of ‘conceal and carry’ permits. Nor will Civitas Media develop databases of permit holders. A poorly crafted internal memo meant to highlight editorial discussions and planning incorrectly indicated that such a database was being planned; it has been considered and rejected,” the statement read.
Fayette County Sheriff Vernon P. Stanforth said that if Civitas’ local publications were to follow through with the order, it would pose a serious threat to permit holders.
“I’m concerned the information, once in the hands of criminals, could pose a threat to both the permit holder and the next door neighbor who has chosen not to carry concealed weapons.” Stanforth told Fayette Advocate.
According to research conducted by Fayette Advocate and the Buckeye Firearms Association, Civitas would have extreme difficulty creating the database because state law prohibits the copying of concealed carry weapon permits.
When Ohio’s concealed carry law was first passed almost ten years ago, a provision inserted by anti-gun then-Govenor Bob Taft (R) allowed journalists access to the lists, even though the law declared such records to be “confidential and…not public records.”
This media access loophole was abused by journalists to such a degree that, in late 2006, Taft was forced to sign a modification to the law which specified that journalists are allowed to view, but not copy, the records. The Ohio Newspaper Association then set about to debate the word “copy” as if they were Bill Clinton defining the word “is,” and in the end it took an opinion issued by the Ohio Attorney General to stop the anti-Second Amendment journalists in their tracks.
According to the opinion by the Ohio Attorney General, the database would be virtually impossible to construct.
“If a journalist submits a signed, written request to the sheriff to view the information described in this division, the sheriff shall grant the journalist’s request,” the opinion reads. “The journalist shall not copy the name, county of residence, or date of birth of each person to or for whom the sheriff has issued, suspended, or revoked a license described in this division.”
Without being able to copy the information, the database couldn’t be constructed unless the journalist has an impeccable memory and can remember thousands of names and addresses by memory.
The Buckeye Firearms Association said that the discussion to make the database is a ploy to target and attack gun owners.
That point was made again in the wake of the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre, when Gannett Company’s The Journal News of White Plains, N.Y. decided to punish people who had nothing to do with the crime by publishing an interactive map with the names and addresses of handgun permit owners in New York’s Westchester and Rockland counties.
Readers responded by publishing personal information about the The Journal News’ staffers, much as Buckeye Firearms Association did in 2007, and other news outlets began documenting thefts of guns from homes on The Journal News map.
State Senator Joe Uecker cited the problems the New York newspaper caused when he introduced Senate Bill 60 last March. The bill would, once and for all, close the media access loophole that currently allows journalists to view but not copy the private, personal information of persons who have obtained a license to carry a concealed handgun from the State of Ohio.
“Law-abiding gun owners who choose to exercise their Second Amendment rights do not deserve to be treated as though they are registered sex offenders, outed on a public list as ‘undesirables,’ which is why we react so strongly to even the ‘idea’ or ‘discussion’ of the building of a database,” said Buckeye Firearms Association Secretary Chad Baus, who originally broke the story on BFA’s website.
Baus added that the company should have thought through their plans since some of their newspapers are in rural parts of the state.
“The fact that this is being considered by a company that owns rural newspapers is amazing,” he said. “The county where I work every day is served by a Civitas newspaper. We are a rural area where, for the majority of people, guns are a part of life. We use them to harvest food, for recreation, as investments, and yes, to protect the ones we love. It is pretty obvious to me that the corporate bigwigs at Civitas don’t have a clue about the markets their newspapers serve, or they’d never have even discussed this idea.”
As previously mentioned, Civitas owns a newspaper in Highland County where local school districts dismiss school for an entire week so students can participate in deer hunting season.
One local resident said that he would be outraged if such a database was created.
“If they create a database like that, for their sake, I hope they have a concealed weapon,” he said. “Because I do have mine; I have several and I also have a good defense attorney.”